Are Shiv Sena and MNS stronger than the government ?

we have seen them do some unnecessary ugly works , also the state government there appears to do nothing much to stop them........ or do u think Shiv Sena and MNS are doing really appreciable work ?|||No poltical party is above the law and Constitution of our country...





To understand the reason why radical political parties like Shiv Sena and MNS are successful to a certain extent, you need to know the mechanism by which they work...





Parties like the Shiv Sena %26amp; MNS are very low on ideologies and have absolutely no ethics...they are more or less dependent on the strong personality and charisma of a single individual (Bal Thackeray for Shiv Sena and Raj Thackeray in case of MNS)...the party workers learn to blindly follow such unscruplous political goons...in case the individual retires or deceases, the party's effectiveness is lost...only another equally influential and charismatic person can keep things moving...this is evident by the fact that Shiv Sena workers were disillusioned with the mild-mannered Udhav Thackeray and Bal Thackeray was forced to come out of retirement...





The Shiv Sena %26amp; MNS have capitalised on the Maharashtrian's frustration and sense of inadequacy...they claim to represent the Marathi people, but they have done nothing productive to improve the life of the common man...their modus operandi is bullying, strong arm tactics, destroying public %26amp; private property, beating up innocent people, moral policing and stopping cricket matches etc...they demand job preferences and reservations for Maharashtrians, which brings into doubt the capability %26amp; competence of the Marathi Manoos to get good jobs on the basis of their own merit, that too in their own state where they have the advantage!!!





These tactics will provide only short-term benefits to the Marathis and will be very detrimental in the long run...however there are lots of short-sighted idiots who support these parties as they want short-cuts to get ahead in life...the situation becomes worse when influential personalities like Amitabh Bachchan kowtow to people like Bal Thackeray to stay in his good books...





In fact the stand of these two parties are often confusing and at odds with each other...both of them claim to be working for the betterment of Maharashtra, but are more like two spindly trees hacking at each other's roots...Bal Thackeray wants to drive SRK out of India, but himself hosts Javed Miandad (who is relative of Dawood Ibrahim) and is his fan...he was also esctatic when Michael Jackson used the toilet at his residence during his visit to India...it is well known that America is supporting Pakistan and sponsoring its terrorist activities, so by his own dubious logic, shouldn't Bal Thackeray have banned Michael Jackson (I have nothing against Michael Jackson)??? Shouldn't Bal Thackeray himself be driven out of India for all this???





Raj Thackeray initially claimed that he has no problems against non-maharashtrians as long as they respect the Marathi Culture and language...now he is claiming that only true-blue Maharashtrians should be given preferences in jobs in this state...by this he has excluded non-maharashtrians who have been born in this state, stayed here for several years and adapted the Marathi culture %26amp; language...but then he claims in his MNS website the he is not an enemy of non-Marathis !!!





Lots of people blindly follow these nefarious political goons and applaud their short-term strategies as these people lack foresight...the Thackerays live ultra-luxurious lifestyles, reminiscent of kings and sultans, whereas the common Marathi Manoos cannot even dream about such a life...





Such political parties are detrimental to the well-being of our country...they believe in the British policy of "Divide %26amp; Rule"....they seek to divide the population on basis of caste, race %26amp; religion...they indulge in caste-divisive and hatred politics...they seek to hound celebrities, sports persons %26amp; industrialists for cheap publicity and flex their political muscle by demanding apologies...they have scant disregard for the law and do not believe in the constitutional right of every Indian to live freely in any corner of our Country...they do this because they believe that they have nothing to lose...





It is not that the state government cannot do anything to stop them...more often than not, when action is initiated against people like Raj Thackeray, they exploit legal loop holes and get away on mere technicalities...





It is time the youth of India stood up and said NO to such opportunistic, unscruplous political goons...|||I had not been to Maharashtra, well so i reply from my analysys of the news and other sources .





They are not stronger , and for that matter no force in the country is stronger than the govt. The slackness and tolerant attitude of govt, both the centre and state, is the only factor calling you to ask this question . I shall call it in action from the side of govt to stop it . if it determines today to do so , it wont take more than fifteen days to gain control over the stupidity of mns or shiv sena .


but for the fifteen days the govt and the people in it will have to forget the term vote banks , and such things .





secondly impartially i don't hear or get any good deeds done by these organizations through news I shall not comment on it . Even if they are doing some appreciable job , let us assume it , That does not empower to do nonsense with others . I hope u agree . May be they do good to the selected. But the matter of whole country is far too important than just a state or its people . It out weighs every small interest.


It is separatism and if the country has to stay further undivided it should not to be encouraged .


No state is self sufficient in all respect, in electricity, agriculture ,business, education, etc. and each state has to interact with other for some thing or other directly or through center for the coexistence.





This is the real fact and shiv sena and mns has to accept it and act wisely in future .|||Dear, a devil effort is devil effort and it is not related to mankind,


Sena and MNS are fighting for their own meat, some times Shiv Sena is doing good but MNS are waste,why north Indians only? why one side favour to Maratha's?


north indians are not indians?don't they have rights to live as other people?





Everything is fair in politics my dear.


We people can stop them,we should take step before government.|||The local parties always have upper hand in street politics. SS %26amp; MNS are in certain ways doing what needs to be done for employment opportunities for the local people. Take for instance the Andhra Pradesh issue, it was a local party which forced the spineless govt to announce Telangana as a separate state.|||It is just question of habit. The Centre had been witness to more serious atrocities in the past - the Hindus being beaten and sent out of Jammu Kashmir, the Sikha being beaten black and blue by congress men, the Karnnadigas beating Tamil workers on Cauvery issue... so many sad tales had been stoically witnessed with pseudo sympathy and weird excuses.. that the SS MNS pathology is unlikely to shock our politicians. They would be counting the vote bank with the Regional Chauvinists that they may lose by any action on the anti national, anti constitutional activities..





We are cursed to have a party least nurturing either a national legacy of patriotism or global ethics of equality etc. They are nearly dysfunctional when Indians after Indians are being killed in Aussie, while an ex President of US travelled all the way to a hostile country to free an American journalist.. Compare the spirit of fraternity / nationality of the Congress leaders! Either it is the domestic terror, pathological price rise unconnected with domestic stock position or production or the fuel crisis, or the chinese atrocities on borders, or whatever danger arising in or out of the country, the govt is damn apathetic and the media never make a hue and cry, for known reasons.. The intellectuals are spending time arguing over inconsequential things.. A State CM is talking about Tamil Conference when his people are finding essential commodities are going beyond economic reach of even middle class people...





SS or MNS or any outfit need not be strong - to threaten our govts. Our govt is least poised to govern country.. they are preoccupied about umpteen other things to consolidate their interests.. The writing on the wall is clear.. The misrule has to come to an end and the laxity shown by rulers is the prelude to their own fall. May be some revolutionary may emerge in future to gather people against the pseudo leaders..!|||That is a situation in one hand,great economists are increasing the prices on the other hand.


Now,as a voter, enjoy the situation,if u can !


It is a bad luck of India.|||they are not and its time the maharashtra govt showed them that...the message from chidambaram ,rahul gandhi and sharukh khan is heartening...i think mns and ss do all this for publicity..maybe they would shut up if we stopped giving them so much attention..|||That is the question striking the minds of every India today, at least I still don't have the answer. Either these goons are more stronger or state government is handicap.|||they r not so but government made them so. because government dont want to decrease their votebanks.|||They are not strong, they are cowards and government of Maharashtra is in no mood to take any action against them because of Marathi vote bank.